Indulge in Homemade Bliss: The Ultimate Copycat Cracker Barrel Mac and Cheese Recipe

There’s something uniquely comforting about a classic mac and cheese, especially when it conjures memories of heartwarming, down-home cooking. This copycat Cracker Barrel Mac and Cheese recipe is meticulously crafted to be incredibly close to the real deal, bringing that beloved taste straight from their famous restaurant to your kitchen. Cracker Barrel is renowned for its simple, yet profoundly satisfying, comfort food, and this recipe embodies that spirit perfectly. It’s not just mac and cheese; it’s a nostalgic journey to the flavors of your favorite roadside eatery, made with an uncomplicated approach that yields extraordinary results.

This dish is more than just a side; it’s an experience. When planning your Thanksgiving menu, or any holiday gathering for that matter, this mac and cheese stands out as a top contender for the ultimate side dish. Its universal appeal makes it a guaranteed crowd-pleaser, effortlessly complementing any main course. It’s quick to prepare, incredibly easy, and let’s be honest, who doesn’t adore a rich, creamy, and perfectly cheesy macaroni and cheese?

Those who have savored Cracker Barrel’s Mac and Cheese understand its unparalleled quality. It’s the best for a reason. Its inherent simplicity, the specific blend of cheeses they use, and their unwavering no-frills approach converge to create a dish that is simply divine. The best creamy sauce, rich and smooth, coats every single noodle, making each bite an absolute delight. Our copycat version captures all these elements, ensuring you can replicate that magic right in your own home.

Why This Cracker Barrel Mac and Cheese Copycat Will Become Your New Favorite

This isn’t just another mac and cheese recipe; it’s a tried-and-true method for achieving culinary perfection with minimal fuss. Here’s what makes this particular version stand out and why it’s destined to become a beloved staple in your kitchen:

• Effortless Pantry Staples: Forget obscure ingredients or specialty store trips. This copycat recipe relies on simple, everyday pantry items that are readily available at any grocery store. It’s a super no-fuss approach, ensuring you can whip up this dish whenever a craving strikes without a last-minute shopping frenzy.
• Blazing Fast Preparation: In today’s busy world, quick and delicious meals are a lifesaver. You can have this comforting dish on the table in just 10-15 minutes, making it an ideal choice for a speedy weeknight family dinner or a last-minute potluck contribution. It’s genuinely that fast!
• Pure, Wholesome Ingredients: Say goodbye to artificial flavors, colors, or preservatives. This homemade mac and cheese boasts only real, wholesome ingredients, guaranteeing a dish that tastes fresh, authentic, and utterly delicious. You’ll know exactly what’s going into your family’s meal.
• Ultimate Comfort Food: There’s a reason mac and cheese is synonymous with comfort. This recipe delivers a warm, gooey, and satisfying experience that will instantly make it one of your favorite comfort foods. It’s the kind of dish that wraps you in a culinary hug, perfect for any occasion when you need a little extra coziness.
• A Guaranteed Satisfying Dinner: Whether served as a standalone meal or a hearty side, this mac and cheese truly makes a satisfying dinner. Its rich flavor and creamy texture are incredibly fulfilling, ensuring everyone at the table leaves happy and content. It’s a guaranteed family favorite that will be requested time and time again.
• Crowd-Pleasing Versatility: While perfect for family dinners, this mac and cheese also scales beautifully for larger gatherings. Its universal appeal makes it an excellent choice for potlucks, holiday feasts, or casual get-togethers. Everyone, from the pickiest eaters to the most discerning foodies, will appreciate its classic charm.

From its ease of preparation to its undeniable deliciousness, this Cracker Barrel-inspired mac and cheese is more than just a recipe; it’s an invitation to create lasting memories around the dinner table.

Unlocking the Ultimate Creaminess: The Keys to a Perfect Mac and Cheese Sauce

Achieving that signature ultra-creamy, velvety mac and cheese sauce, just like Cracker Barrel’s, isn’t a mystery. It comes down to a few critical choices that elevate the dish from good to absolutely phenomenal.

The Cheese Selection: The Heart of the Creaminess

The Cheeses: For this authentic copycat recipe, we prioritize a good quality Colby cheese. Why Colby? Because it possesses an exceptional melting quality. It becomes beautifully smooth without turning greasy or stringy, which is precisely what gives the sauce its signature uniform texture and rich, mild flavor. It melts seamlessly into the roux, creating that luxurious mouthfeel we all crave. While Colby is our top recommendation for authenticity, other excellent melting cheeses that can achieve a similar smooth consistency include mild cheddar or Monterey Jack. These cheeses offer a balanced flavor profile and melt without clumping, ensuring a consistently delightful sauce.

The Importance of Shredding Your Own Cheese

Shred Your Own Cheese: This is arguably one of the most crucial tips for a truly smooth and creamy sauce. While pre-shredded cheeses are convenient, they come coated in anti-caking agents, typically starches like cellulose. These starches, while preventing clumping in the bag, can prevent the cheese from melting properly and can introduce a slightly grainy or gritty texture to your sauce. By taking a few extra minutes to shred your own block of cheese, you ensure that only pure cheese enters your sauce, resulting in an impeccably smooth, luscious, and superior-tasting mac and cheese. This small effort makes a monumental difference in the final texture.

Mastering the Roux: The Foundation of Flavor

Beyond the cheese, the roux — a mixture of butter and flour — forms the foundation of your creamy sauce. A well-made roux thickens the milk evenly and provides a base for the cheese to melt into. Cooking the flour sufficiently in butter (for at least a minute or two) helps eliminate any raw flour taste, contributing to a richer, more developed flavor in your final sauce. This combination of quality cheese and a perfectly executed roux is the ultimate secret to an ultra-creamy mac and cheese that rivals the best.

Gather Your Ingredients: What You’ll Need for Cracker Barrel Mac and Cheese

Crafting this incredible copycat Cracker Barrel Mac and Cheese starts with a simple yet essential list of ingredients. The beauty of this recipe lies in its reliance on common items you likely already have on hand, ensuring a fuss-free cooking experience. Remember, quality ingredients, even simple ones, make a huge difference in the final taste and texture of your dish.

Here’s a snapshot of the core components you’ll need. For the exact quantities and a printer-friendly version, please refer to the detailed recipe card located at the bottom of this post.

• Elbow Macaroni: The classic choice for macaroni and cheese, its small, curved shape perfectly cradles the creamy sauce.
• Water: For cooking the pasta to that perfect al dente bite.
• Salted Butter: Unsalted butter is preferred, as it gives you more control over the overall sodium content. It forms the base of our rich roux.
• All-Purpose Flour: The thickening agent for our velvety cheese sauce, creating a smooth and luscious consistency.
• Whole Milk: Warmed whole milk is crucial for a rich, creamy sauce. The higher fat content contributes significantly to the dish’s decadent texture.
• Colby Cheese: The star of the show! As mentioned, high-quality Colby cheese is key for its superior melting properties and authentic Cracker Barrel flavor. Remember to shred it yourself for the best results.
• Nutmeg: A pinch of nutmeg might seem unexpected, but it’s a secret ingredient that subtly enhances the cheese flavor, adding depth and warmth without overpowering the dish.
• Salt and Freshly Ground Black Pepper: Essential for seasoning to taste. Don’t be shy about tasting and adjusting!
• Fresh Parsley (for garnish): An optional but delightful touch for a pop of color and fresh aroma.

Gathering these simple ingredients is the first exciting step toward creating a truly remarkable, restaurant-quality mac and cheese in your own home. Get ready for an explosion of flavor!

Crafting Perfection: Step-by-Step Instructions for Cracker Barrel Mac and Cheese

Making this copycat Cracker Barrel Mac and Cheese is a straightforward process, even for novice cooks. Follow these steps to achieve a perfectly creamy, cheesy, and utterly delicious dish. This is an overview of the key recipe steps; for more detailed instructions, including precise measurements and timings, please refer to the comprehensive recipe card at the bottom of this post.

• Step 1: Cook the Macaroni to Al Dente. Begin by bringing a medium saucepan of generously salted water to a rolling boil. Add your elbow macaroni and cook it according to the package instructions. The key here is to cook the pasta just until it’s al dente – meaning it’s firm to the bite, as it will continue to cook slightly in the hot cheese sauce. Once cooked, drain the macaroni thoroughly and set it aside. Do not rinse the cooked macaroni noodles! The starch clinging to the pasta will actually help thicken your cheese sauce and contribute to its smooth, rich texture and flavor.
• Step 2: Prepare the Roux. While your noodles are cooking, melt the unsalted butter in a medium to large cast iron skillet over medium heat. Once the butter is fully melted and slightly shimmering, add the all-purpose flour. Whisk continuously for one to two minutes. This step is crucial for cooking out the raw flour taste and creating the base for your rich cheese sauce. The mixture will form a thick paste.
• Step 3: Gradually Add Warm Milk. Slowly, very slowly, pour in the warmed whole milk, a little at a time, while continuously whisking. At first, the mixture will be quite thick and paste-like, but as you gradually incorporate more milk, it will begin to thin out and transform into a smooth, creamy sauce. Patience is key here to avoid lumps and ensure a velvety consistency. Keep whisking until all the milk is incorporated and the sauce is smooth and slightly thickened.
• Step 4: Incorporate the Cheese and Seasoning. Reduce the heat to low. Add two cups of your freshly grated Colby cheese to the milk mixture, stirring constantly until it is completely melted and fully incorporated into the sauce. The sauce should be smooth and luxurious. Now, add your seasoning blend – a pinch of nutmeg, salt, and freshly ground black pepper to taste. Stir again to ensure all the flavors are well distributed. Taste the sauce and adjust seasonings if necessary.
• Step 5: Combine Macaroni and Sauce. Gently add the drained, cooked macaroni noodles into the cheese sauce. Using a spoon or spatula, slowly fold the noodles into the sauce until every piece of macaroni is thoroughly coated in the rich, creamy goodness. Be careful not to mash the noodles.
• Step 6: Broil to Golden Perfection. Sprinkle the remaining half cup of grated Colby cheese evenly over the top of the creamy mac and cheese in the skillet. Place the skillet under a hot broiler for just one to two minutes. Watch it very closely! You’re looking for the cheese on top to melt and turn a beautiful golden brown and bubbly. This step adds a delightful crispness and extra layer of cheesy flavor.
• Step 7: Garnish and Serve. Carefully remove the skillet from the broiler. For a touch of freshness and vibrant color, sprinkle with a teaspoon of fresh chopped parsley before serving immediately.

Hint: The starch from unrinsed pasta is a secret weapon! It contributes significantly to the sauce’s body, helping it cling to the macaroni and creating a more cohesive and delicious final product.

Serving this homemade Cracker Barrel Mac and Cheese hot and fresh ensures the best texture and flavor. Prepare for rave reviews!

Elevate Your Dish: Creative Recipe Variations and Smart Substitutions

While our copycat Cracker Barrel Mac and Cheese recipe is a masterpiece on its own, don’t hesitate to personalize it! These variations and substitutions can add new dimensions of flavor and texture, or simply help you adapt the recipe to what you have on hand or specific dietary needs.

• Alternative Flours: Instead of traditional all-purpose flour, you could use whole wheat flour for a slightly nuttier flavor and added fiber. For a gluten-free option, a 1:1 gluten-free flour blend can work wonderfully to thicken your roux.
• A Hint of Spice: For an extra layer of complexity and a subtle tang that really brings out the cheese flavor, try adding a touch of ground mustard (about ½ teaspoon) to your cheese sauce. It’s a classic mac and cheese enhancer!
• Butter Alternatives: If you’re looking to reduce dairy fat or can’t use butter, you could start off your roux with a neutral-flavored oil like canola oil or even olive oil. Ensure it’s a high-quality oil to maintain flavor.
• Milk Options: While whole milk provides the richest, creamiest texture, you can certainly use skim milk if that’s what you have. Just be aware that the sauce might be slightly less decadent. For an even more luxurious sauce, substitute a portion of the whole milk with heavy cream.
• Exploring Cheese Types: Cracker Barrel famously uses Colby cheese for its excellent melt and mild flavor profile. However, this is your kitchen! Feel free to experiment.
  • Avoid Pre-Shredded: As mentioned, try to avoid pre-shredded cheese due to the anti-caking starches, which can make your sauce grainy. Always shred your own from a block.
  • Sharpness Factor: Using a more aged cheese, like sharp cheddar, will introduce a bold, tangy sharpness to your mac and cheese. A sharp white cheddar cheese can also offer a sophisticated twist.
  • Cheese Blends: Consider a blend of cheeses! A combination of Colby, mild cheddar, and a touch of Gruyère or Fontina can create an incredibly complex and flavorful sauce.
• Flavorful Cooking Liquid: For an added layer of savory depth, use low sodium chicken broth to cook your noodles instead of plain salted water. You could also substitute some of the milk in the sauce with chicken or vegetable broth.
• Aromatic Additions: Introduce some aromatic flair with about a ½ teaspoon of garlic powder stirred into the cheese sauce. For a fresh kick, a clove or two of minced fresh garlic sautéed with the butter before adding the flour can elevate the flavor profile significantly.
• Textural Crunch: For a delightful contrast, sprinkle some buttery bread crumbs (panko works great!) on top of the mac and cheese before broiling or baking. This adds a fantastic crispy topping.
• Savory Vegetables: For a touch of savory sweetness, sauté some finely diced onions (about ¼ cup) in the butter before adding the flour. They’ll melt into the sauce, adding a wonderful depth.
• Indulgent Creaminess: For an exceptionally rich and decadent mac and cheese, swap out all or half of the whole milk for heavy cream. This will yield an incredibly thick and luxurious sauce.
• Bacon Bliss: Who doesn’t love bacon? Crumble some cooked, crispy bacon over the top just before serving for an irresistible salty crunch and smoky flavor that pairs perfectly with the creamy cheese.

These ideas are just starting points. Don’t be afraid to get creative and tailor this Cracker Barrel Mac and Cheese recipe to your personal taste preferences!

Essential Gear: The Equipment for Perfect Mac and Cheese

The following are affiliate links. We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.

While you don’t need a gourmet kitchen to make incredible mac and cheese, having the right tools can certainly enhance the cooking process and the final outcome. For this particular recipe, a few key pieces of equipment will make all the difference:

The Cast Iron Skillet Advantage

Whenever I prepare a macaroni and cheese dish, my go-to vessel is always a trusty cast iron skillet. The main reason for this preference is its incredible versatility and heat retention. A cast iron skillet provides wonderfully even heat distribution, which is crucial for a perfectly cooked roux and a consistently smooth cheese sauce. Furthermore, its oven-safe nature means you can effortlessly transition from stovetop sauce preparation to finishing the dish under the broiler, achieving that beautiful golden-brown, bubbly top layer without having to transfer the entire dish. It’s the best way to ensure uniform cooking and a delightful crust.

For those looking to replicate the exact setup I use, I’ve included affiliate links for the specific type of equipment, complete with product information, in the recipe card section below. These are the tools that consistently deliver the best results in my kitchen.

Alternative Baking Options

If you don’t own a cast iron skillet, or simply prefer to use a different dish, you can absolutely bake this mac and cheese in a traditional casserole dish. Once your creamy cheese sauce is prepared on the stovetop and combined with the macaroni, simply transfer the mixture to your favorite casserole dish. Then, you can finish it off in the oven, perhaps with a sprinkle of extra cheese or breadcrumbs on top, creating a classic “Cracker Barrel Mac and Cheese oven baked recipe.” This method works beautifully for a slightly softer, more casserole-like texture, and it’s perfect for feeding a crowd.

Basic Kitchen Tools

Beyond the skillet or casserole dish, you’ll also want to have a good whisk for making the roux and sauce, a medium saucepan for cooking the macaroni, a sturdy spatula for folding the noodles into the sauce, and a cheese grater for freshly shredding your cheese. These fundamental tools will ensure a smooth and enjoyable cooking experience from start to finish.

Perfect Pairings: What to Serve with Your Cracker Barrel Mac and Cheese

This Cracker Barrel Mac and Cheese is incredibly versatile and pairs beautifully with a wide array of main courses and other side dishes. Whether you’re planning a holiday feast, a casual family dinner, or a backyard BBQ, here are some fantastic ideas to complete your meal, including more beloved copycat Cracker Barrel recipes and Southern classics:

Cracker Barrel Inspired Companions

• Cracker Barrel Chicken and Rice: Recreate a full Cracker Barrel experience with another satisfying copycat recipe – tender chicken and flavorful rice.
• Cracker Barrel Fried Apples: A classic sweet and tangy side that beautifully balances the richness of the mac and cheese. This popular dish from the famous restaurant is always a hit.
• Cracker Barrel Sweet Potato Casserole: Pure perfection in a casserole dish, this sweet potato casserole is made just like Cracker Barrel does it, offering a delightful contrast of flavors and textures.

Hearty Southern Sides and More

• Creamy Cheese Grits: Delicious southern-style cheesy grits are perfect for breakfast, lunch, or dinner, offering another level of creamy indulgence.
• Fluffy Cajun Cornbread: This cornbread recipe is surprisingly easy and another fantastic skillet creation, providing a perfect accompaniment to any comfort meal.
• Cranberry Apple Rice Pilaf: A very festive and fun Thanksgiving side dish that brings a touch of brightness and fruity notes.
• Savory Baked Oyster Dressing: This rich and flavorful dressing goes great as another possible, more adventurous Thanksgiving side dish.
• Slow Cooker Cajun Mac and Cheese: If you’re looking for another mac and cheese variation with a spicy kick, this slow cooker recipe is absolutely amazing and perfect for busy days.

No matter what you choose to serve alongside it, this Cracker Barrel Mac and Cheese is sure to be the star of the show!

Storing Your Delicious Leftovers: Maximizing Freshness

One of the best things about making a generous batch of this Cracker Barrel Mac and Cheese recipe is the joy of having leftovers! Storing them properly ensures you can enjoy that comforting flavor for days to come. Here’s how to keep your mac and cheese fresh and delicious:

Refrigerator Storage

This Cracker Barrel Mac and Cheese is incredibly easy to store in the refrigerator. Once cooled to room temperature, transfer any remaining mac and cheese into an airtight container. Alternatively, you can cover the top of the skillet or casserole dish tightly with plastic wrap or aluminum foil. Stored in the refrigerator, it will maintain its quality and delicious flavor for up to 4 days.

Reheating: For the best results when reheating, use a microwave. Place a portion in a microwave-safe dish, add a splash of milk or a small pat of butter to help loosen it up and restore creaminess, then heat in 30-second intervals, stirring in between, until heated through. You can also reheat gently on the stovetop over low heat, stirring frequently, adding a bit of milk or butter as needed.

Freezer Storage for Longer Enjoyment

Yes, you can successfully freeze this homemade mac and cheese! Freezing is a fantastic option if you’ve made a large batch or want to prepare a meal ahead of time for future convenience.

1. Cool Completely: Ensure the mac and cheese is completely cooled before freezing.
2. Portioning: For easier reheating, portion the mac and cheese into individual servings or family-sized portions.
3. Freezer-Safe Container: Transfer the cooled mac and cheese into a freezer-safe container or heavy-duty freezer bags. Press out any excess air if using bags.
4. Labeling: Always label your containers with the date, so you know exactly when it was made.
5. Freezing Duration: Properly stored, your frozen mac and cheese can last for up to 6 months in the freezer.

Reheating from Frozen: To reheat, thaw the mac and cheese in the refrigerator overnight. Then, reheat in the microwave or on the stovetop as described above, adding a bit more milk or butter if it seems too dry. You can also reheat directly from frozen in the oven, covered with foil, at 350°F (175°C) until heated through, stirring occasionally and adding liquid as needed.

With these storage tips, you can savor the comforting taste of Cracker Barrel Mac and Cheese whenever the craving strikes!

Frequently Asked Questions: Your Cracker Barrel Mac and Cheese Queries Answered

If you’ve tried this delightful Cracker Barrel Mac and Cheese Recipe or any other fantastic recipe on my site, please let me know in the comment section below how it turned out! We absolutely love hearing from our wonderful readers and cherish your feedback!

If you adore this recipe as much as we do, please consider giving it a 5-star rating! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Your ratings and reviews are incredibly helpful and encouraging.

You can also follow me on PINTEREST, FACEBOOK and INSTAGRAM to discover more amazing recipes, cooking tips, and culinary inspiration!

Print Recipe
Pin Recipe

Cracker Barrel Mac and Cheese Recipe